Aerosol optical depth comparison between GAW-PFR and AERONET-Cimel radiometers from long-term (2005ā2015) 1āmin synchronous measurements
August 9, 2019
A comprehensive comparison of more than 70ā000Ā synchronous 1āmin aerosol optical depth (AOD) data from three Global Atmosphere Watch precision-filter radiometers (GAW-PFR), traceable to the World AOD reference, and 15 Aerosol Robotic Network Cimel radiometers (AERONET-Cimel), calibrated individually with the Langley plot technique, was performed for four common or ānearā wavelengths, 380, 440, 500 and 870ānm, in the period 2005ā2015.
The goal of this study is to assess whether, despite the marked technical differences between both networks (AERONET, GAW-PFR) and the number of instruments used, their long-term AOD data are comparable and consistent.
The percentage of data meeting the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) traceability requirements (95ā% of the AOD differences of an instrument compared to the WMO standards lie within specific limits) isĀ >92ā% at 380ānm,Ā >95ā% at 440ānm and 500ānm, and 98ā% at 870ānm, with the results being quite similar for both AERONET versionĀ 2 (V2) and versionĀ 3 (V3). For the data outside these limits, the contribution of calibration and differences in the calculation of the optical depth contribution due to Rayleigh scattering andĀ O3Ā andĀ NO2Ā absorption have a negligible impact. For AODĀ >0.1, a small but non-negligible percentage (ā¼1.9ā%) of the AOD data outside the WMO limits at 380ānm can be partly assigned to the impact of dust aerosol forward scattering on the AOD calculation due to the different field of view of the instruments. Due to this effect the GAW-PFR provides AOD values, which areĀ ā¼3ā% lower at 380ānm andĀ ā¼2ā% lower at 500ānm compared with AERONET-Cimel. The comparison of the Ć ngstrƶm exponent (AE) shows that under non-pristine conditions (AODā>0.03Ā and AEā<1) the AE differences remainĀ <0.1. This long-term comparison shows an excellent traceability of AERONET-Cimel AOD with the World AOD reference at 440, 500 and 870ānm channels and a fairly good agreement at 380ānm, although AOD should be improved in the UV range.
Citation: Cuevas, E., Romero-Campos, P. M., Kouremeti, N., Kazadzis, S., RƤisƤnen, P., GarcĆa, R. D., Barreto, A., Guirado-Fuentes, C., Ramos, R., Toledano, C., Almansa, F., and Grƶbner, J.: Aerosol optical depth comparison between GAW-PFR and AERONET-Cimel radiometers from long-term (2005ā2015) 1āmin synchronous measurements, Atmos. Meas. Tech., 12, 4309ā4337, https://doi.org/10.5194/amt-12-4309-2019, 2019.